There’s something special about the local Italian food you’ll find on the Gulf Coast. It’s deeply traditional, yet completely different from Italian fare anywhere else in the world — including Italy. Sometimes it’s the names we use: “red gravy” rather than pasta sauce, for instance. Sometimes it’s the way we use ingredients, such as our liberal use of breadcrumbs. And sometimes it’s every aspect of the dish, all at once — the muffaletta sandwich is beloved local Italian fare, but don’t bother looking for it in Italy. They’ve never heard of it.
To get some sense of how our local Italian fare came to be this way, I reached out to Michael Gulotta, the executive chef and co-founder of TANA, the celebrated new Italian restaurant in Old Metairie. He told me that the food any region eats is born from its climate, driven by agriculture, and inseparable from its history.
“New foods are born from different cultures marrying each other, and that’s especially true around here,” said Gulotta. He used his family as an example. “TANA is named after my great-grandmother. She would make a really simple, traditional marinara, which was just a little garlic, some chili flakes and canned tomatoes, simmered during the day.”
But her sister — whose husband was from New Orleans — had to do things a little differently. “To make the same type of sauce, her sister would first caramelize the ‘trinity’ — peppers, celery and onion. Then she would add tomatoes and let that simmer. Sometimes she would even add a pork hock in there and make it really rich. In other words, she brought South Louisiana flavors to a traditional Italian sauce to make her husband happy.”
He explained: “Food and love are about trying to bridge the gap.”
For decades, Gulotta has helped shaped the local palate. A New Orleans native, he was trained at the Chef John Folse Culinary Institute at Nicholls State. After graduation, he returned to the city and began cooking at Marisol in the Marigny neighborhood, and then for Chef Emeril Lagasse at Delmonico in the Lower Garden District.
Not long after Chef John Besh hired him at Restaurant August, Gulotta received a life-changing acceptance letter from a cooking school in Italy in the small town of Costigliole d’Asti in the Piedmont region of northwestern Italy. The school also helped him land a job at Ristorante Marco Bal along the Ligurian coast. Besh was supportive of his new chef de cuisine, and held Gulotta’s position for him while he studied abroad. He underwent intensive training in the art of authentic Italian cuisine — everything from charcuterie to pasta-making. When he returned to his position at August, he began developing an idea for an Italian restaurant of his own — one that would leverage his Sicilian background and Ligurian studies. He continued working on the idea even as he opened his first restaurant, MOPHO, in 2014, and two years later, his second establishment, MAYPOP.
His plans came to fruition in 2023, when he opened his most ambitious restaurant yet: TANA, a neighborhood family Italian restaurant located in Old Metairie. Gulotta spent his entire career planning TANA. Its menu brings together the classic culinary training he received in Northern Italy, the traditional Sicilian food he ate at home growing up, and the colorful palate you can only get as a Louisiana native.
Though TANA is refined, Gulotta told me, at its heart it is an accessible neighborhood Italian experience. “The food is fresh and comforting,” he said. Popular on the menu is squid ink fusilli tossed with crabmeat and saffron, which was heavily inspired by his time in Liguria. But also among the most ordered dishes at TANA is Oysters Bordelaise, an “Old New Orleans” Sicilian tradition — and something else you won’t find in Italy.
“Oysters Bordelaise is a 100% Sicilian representation of a French dish,” he said. Bordelaise, traditionally, is veal stock with Bordeaux wine, finished with bone marrow: a very rich dish. “Instead, we took olive oil and chili flakes and garlic — the things I was cooking with when I was in Italy — and put it over Gulf Coast oysters. We call that ‘Bordelaise,’ if that makes any sense.”
That sort of thing happens all the time around here, he said. “What we call ‘andouille’ was created by Germans settling on Bayou Des Allemands. They built smokehouses and they sold the meat that they smoked under a French name, because people would buy French products.” It gets even more complicated than that, however. “The name comes from the base of ‘andouillette,’ which is a French sausage made by stuffing pork innards into an intestine, and boiling it.”
From the same name, you get a sausage called ‘nduja, from the Calabria region of Italy. “It’s this really amazing salami gentile: meat that’s been ground up with heavy spices and paprika, and then aged. You spread ‘nduja on bread and eat it,” he said, and added: “So that’s basically the same name for three entirely different products — and the only one that’s really not good is the traditional French one!”
The story of local Italian food is inseparable from the story of American immigration. The first great wave of Italian immigrants arrived in the United States in the 19th century. Most came from Sicily and Southern Italy, which had endured prolonged political, economic and agricultural hardships. The United States was a meaningful, enticing path out of poverty.
The Italian immigrants settled disproportionately in Louisiana. This is because after the Civil War and the abolition of slavery, plantations needed workers, and state organizations began actively recruiting farmers from Italy. For Sicilians, New Orleans made perfect sense: The city had a warm, coastal climate and a strong Catholic culture similar to their own, offering familiar social structures on which to build a life.
Long-standing trade routes connected Palermo and the Port of New Orleans, so getting there was easy. Ships already carried lemons, olives and wine one way, and brought cotton, timber and produce the other. Captains were happy to sell cheap tickets to passengers willing to ride alongside the cargo; they were sailing the routes anyway.
By the 1870s, the lower French Quarter — particularly along Decatur Street, between St. Peter and Esplanade — had become a Sicilian enclave. People started calling it Little Palermo. Many personal, commercial and culinary success stories emerged from Little Palermo, including the businesses that would ultimately become Dole, Progresso and Chisesi. Each of the companies had similar origins, typically related to importing, sales or farming, and followed similar patterns: Stands became storefronts, horse-drawn wagons became trucks, and small businesses became flourishing enterprises, forming the foundation of the local Italian food profile.
New Orleans at the beginning of the 1900s had become one of the most important hubs for pasta manufacturing in the world. At its peak, there were 12 macaroni factories in the French Quarter alone. One was even the largest in the United States, producing 10,000 pounds of pasta per day. Pasta making — which was seasonal back home — became a year-round activity in humid Louisiana because of two innovations: hydraulic steam presses for making pasta faster, and climate-controlled rooms for drying it. Before machinery came along, pasta was made by hand. Suddenly, it was available on grocery store shelves.
We still feel the effects of Little Palermo. It’s one reason why old school New Orleanians call pasta “macaroni,” regardless of its shape; that’s a local affectation. Newly arrived Sicilians referred to any dry pasta as maccarruni, a word that soon became anglicized as “macaroni.” Because the macaroni business was so prominent in the city, locals followed the Sicilian tradition, and called everything macaroni: tiny tubes, sticks, shells, spirals — you name it. This is also why New Orleans macaroni and cheese is traditionally made with long pasta.
Locals also have a tradition of referring to pasta sauce as “red gravy.” At its simplest, the reason is that when Italian immigrants came to New Orleans, many locals had never heard of the tomato sauce the new arrivals were selling. They’d heard of gravy though, so Italian immigrants explained it in terms anyone could understand: it’s red gravy. There was also a translation aspect to the name. In Italian, the slow-simmered sauce made from animal fat and meat drippings is called “sugo.” The only analogous English word that fits that same description is “gravy.” People in New Orleans and along the Gulf Coast love nothing if not a good tradition (not to even mention how much they love gravy of any kind), so it’s safe to say that those names are here to stay.
There’s another aspect to the immigration story that makes our local Italian cuisine so special. “I have a good friend who is a manager at Restaurant August,” said Gulotta. “He was one of my opening sous chefs for Maypop. He grew up with other Italians in Philly, where they would still make salsiccia — they would still make salami in their basement. They still speak Italian. What’s different about being Italian here in New Orleans is that this city has an amazing ability to assimilate all its cultures — everyone becomes a New Orleanian.”
That’s not to say locals give up their roots, however. “Growing up, my family would put out bowls of olives and breadsticks — the grissini. But man, we were also cooking gumbo and eating red beans and rice,” he said. “In New Orleans, we assimilate everything. And I think what’s so cool about New Orleans neighborhood Italian restaurants is that they really became part of the Gulf Coast culture.”
The changes went both ways. He explained that, during his time in Sicily, you’d see pasta con le sarde everywhere. The dish is made with finely chopped sardines and anchovies atop pasta, along with fennel and breadcrumbs. “It’s an ancient pasta dish and, here in New Orleans, I still make it for the St. Joseph’s Day parade in the French Quarter,” he said. “But you don’t see restaurants here serving pasta con le sarde. We just don’t do that. We come up with our own new versions of dishes.”
Famously among them are stuffed artichokes. “Obviously you can get stuffed artichokes the traditional way, which is the butter and the Italian breadcrumbs and all that,” he said. “But the good ones are stuffed with shrimp and crabmeat and drizzled with butter sauce because that’s what we do here. We take those French and Creole influences, and we add the Italian influences.”
Defining the boundaries of Italian cuisine can be a complicated question, Gulotta explained, because there’s no monolithic Italian food culture. Italy is dotted with countless micro-climates (and thus, different ingredients), and every little town has its own specialty dish — and they probably call that dish by different names. “For me, the main part of Italian cooking — and it’s all very personal, which makes it fun, so this is just my definition — is that it all comes back to a mixture of olive oil, garlic and chili flakes,” he said. “That’s the starting point for everything that I did when I cooked in Italy. Every pan started with those three things, no matter where it went after that.”
When millions of Italian immigrants arrived in the United States at the turn of the 20th century, the barriers separating those hyper-local Italian dishes broke down. Suddenly, in America, you weren’t a Calabrian or a Neapolitan — you were an Italian, and the different regional cooking styles and recipes began to merge. American Italian cuisine developed from there, taking advantage of this nation’s bounty.
First, the continent awaiting them was replete with plentiful access to meat. If you wanted seafood, you had things like crabs just waiting for you in Lake Pontchartrain — free food for the taking. Also, the mass-market industrialization of vegetable canning gave Italian immigrants year-round access to an ingredient they were already very familiar with: the tomato. Giant meatballs, new cheeses and heavy simmered red sauces quickly appealed to American palates.
“American Italian is so much heavier than traditional true Italian, with all the smothering and cheese and all that stuff,” said Gulotta. “Something I try to teach all my cooks at TANA is that when you go to Italy, your pasta shouldn’t be super saucy. Yes, it should have a really nice sauce, but when you do it properly, the sauce should be emulsified in the pasta — not sitting on top, heavy and gloopy.”
Here, there is a constant give-and-take between Italian cuisine, Italian-American cuisine and our Gulf Coast Italian cuisine. Local barbecue shrimp is one such example. “The traditional barbecue shrimp that my mom would make was just garlic, olive oil, chili flake, parsley, butter and maybe a little paprika — just broiled in the oven and served with crusty bread.” In the mid-1950s, Pascal’s Manale, an Italian-Creole restaurant in the Uptown neighborhood, gave the Italian dish a New Orleans reinvention, with Worcestershire sauce, plenty of butter and Creole spices. (Contrary to the name, the local Italian dish isn’t even barbecued — it’s cooked in a skillet.)
“Later, especially because of Emeril’s influence, the dish had morphed almost into a French dish, because his version was so delicious,” said Gulotta. Local Italian restaurants on the Gulf Coast now primarily serve barbecue shrimp with a French-style sauce with lots of heavy cream and Worcestershire, making it extremely rich. It contrasts starkly with the original preparation in Italy. “What my mom made was rich, too, but it wasn’t cream-based. With our Sicilian heritage, you’re never going to see heavy cream — it’s always going to be finished with quality olive oil. That’s what I love teaching my cooks at TANA.”
America’s seemingly unlimited supply of beef also elevated veal from the delicacy that it is in Sicily to the staple ingredient that it became in local Italian. “When you’re in Italy, man, it’s all pork and lamb, because they don’t have as much land,” said Gulotta. “That’s why prosciutto and guanciale and pancetta are so synonymous with Italian.” Beef in Italy is much more prized — and far different from what we have here. Their cows aren’t fed massive amounts of corn, so the beef is not nearly as marbled and fatty. “That’s why, anytime an American travels to Europe, as soon as they get back to America, they go out and buy a steak. Our steak is just more tender.”
There’s also a dairy aspect to veal’s popularity here. In order for a cow to produce milk, it has to have babies — and Americans love their milk. “Italians came over, and veal was widely accessible and tender. They jumped in and started using it in so many dishes,” said Gulotta. These days, veal isn’t prominent as it once was in Gulf Coast restaurants, but TANA still keeps it on the menu. “Really, I think you’ll find it in every Italian place on the Gulf Coast. You can’t have an Italian restaurant without veal parmesan.” — at least, not in the U.S.
Even with such a mainstay dish, however, the contrast between Italian and local Italian manifests: “Here, we usually bread it, fry it and bake it and cover it with cheese. Traditional Sicilian is lighter, with less breading.” In fact, the classic Italian preparation that goes into veal parmesan was more commonly applied to eggplant, which was a cheap garden crop that anyone could grow in their backyards. “Eggplant parmesan is a Sicilian staple, but it is simply sliced eggplant, tomato and cheese that’s baked. It’s not breaded and fried. Traditionally, the eggplant was fried without breading before being layered with tomato sauce and cheese.
When Gulotta opened TANA, there were some Italian home recipes he grew up eating that he knew from the start would be on the menu. “Chicken alla Tana is our number-one selling dish. It was a comfort food that my great-grandmother would make, and then my grandmother made it, and now my mom makes it — which is funny, because my mom’s actually French and Irish.” It’s another example of food and love bridging the gap, and it’s Gulotta’s favorite dish. It uses simple rustic ingredients: chicken, onions, potatoes, tomatoes and peppers, seasoned with garlic, fresh herbs, butter and extra-virgin olive oil.
In the family recipe, everything is layered into a deep pan and thrown into the oven; as it roasts, the fat renders out of the chicken skin and fuses with the butter, olive oil and released vegetable juices. This leaves a rich, brothy sauce at the bottom. At TANA, he elevates the technique without changing the soul of the dish: half-chickens are brined overnight, then roasted on the bone. Potatoes are cooked ahead of time directly in rendered chicken fat, butter and olive oil. Bones are removed from the chicken, and the pan drippings are emulsified with a house-made oregano butter into a sauce.
“Really simple ingredients, right? One of the hallmarks of true traditional Italian, the epitome of what I grew up with, of just simple Italian cooking.”
And best of all, it’s a style of cooking that anyone at home can do. As Gulotta explained, it only requires keeping a few basic items in your kitchen that are easily found on the shelves of any local Rouses Market.
“It starts with chili flakes, garlic and olive oil,” he said. “Always. That’s the easy first thing everyone needs in their pantry. That’s the basis for everything.” Someone who wants to really lean into traditional Italian would get anchovies as well.
“If you wanted to make a really simple Italian dish, you could do a pasta alla norma, which is just roasted eggplant, garlic, chilies, olive oil and pasta all tossed together,” he said. “But then you know what else is really simple Italian? If you go and grab some burrata and grab some prosciutto and a little extra virgin olive oil and aged balsamic vinegar. Put that on a plate with some focaccia bread, toasted. I mean, that’s about as Italian as it gets, and Rouses Markets carries all of it.”
With a little time and a little practice, anyone can turn Italian into local Italian. You need only a couple of family recipes, a little adventurousness, and a lot of love. “You know, immigrants brought the techniques and the habits,” said Chef Gulotta. “The Gulf Coast supplies the seafood, the produce, and the French, Creole, and Cajun influences — and most important, the appetite. And generations of cooks pick and choose the best parts of it all.”
